Monday, 24 May 2010

TC-20 III and the 70-200mm f/2,8 VRII

Arctic Tern, Norway
D3s, 70-200mm f/2,8 + TC-20III (focal 400mm), 1/4000sek @ f/5,6, ISO800, handheld

After my post yesterday on my experience on the TC-20 III, I was asked how it performed with the new 70-200mm f/2,8 VRII. Well, it sure was a legitimate question since this is one of the lenses that the TC-20 III was intended for - whilst the 500mm f/4 in my previous post was not. As usual I like to experience how the gear works in the field and not in some clinical lab test, after all that is what matters in the end for most of us... One of the more challenging species to work with is the Terns. I set out to photograph some at my local colony of Common and Arctic Terns, armed with the D3s, 70-200mm f/2,8 VRIII and the TC-20 III. In addition I brought a test specimen of the brand new 200-400mm f/4G ED VR II. This lens will be out in stores on the 28th of May, and I have got the opportunity to try one out for a week. I will post my review later on this week. As a teaser I would like to mention it works well with the TC-20 III.

Now, back to the 70-200mm x TC-20 III combo. I spent approximately one hour with the birds, and shooting about 250 frames under very shifting light conditions. All images were shot handheld, and the VR was on at all time, set to Active mode. I was working with fast flying subjects, which is a challenge even with fast lenses like the 300mm f/2,8 and the 70-200mm f/2,8 straight. That is why I was rather surprised how well the autofocus performed with the TC-20 III attached, both with centre point and other focus points chosen. Sharpness was also good. Of course, compared with the 70-200mm straight it is not as crisp, but is works very well, and would not hesitate to put it on whenever needed. I will let the images below speak for themselves.

I did not try it with the 300mm f/2,8, but I expect it to perform just as well. I can only imagine how it will work with the 400mm f/2,8 - that should be a killer combination!

Arctic Tern, Norway
D3s, 70-200mm f/2,8 + TC-20III (focal 380mm), 1/2500sek @ f/8, ISO800, handheld

Arctic Tern, Norway
D3s, 70-200mm f/2,8 + TC-20III (focal 360mm), 1/8000sek @ f/5,6, ISO800, handheld

100 % crop of the file above - no work has been done to this file

8 comments:

Lasse said...

Hoppas det går bra med svenska också....:-))
Otroligt fina bilder på tärnan. Bild 2 är magisk!

Matis Vaht said...

Härliga bilder :) Verkar som TC-20 III är en höjdare.

Knut-Sverre said...

Konverter og 70-200 er jo en særs attraktiv kombinasjon for de lange turene. En 300 / 2,8 med konverter tynger godt i sekken...

Monica Helén said...

hm. Jeg leste ikke det forrige innlegget ditt og det tror jeg at jeg skal gjøre. Dette er en sak som gjør at du får større brennvidde? (om jeg har forstått rett).
Utrolig bra resultater, overrasket over den croppede, -fått med masse detaljer der jo.. =)

Øyvind Antonsen said...

Det ville vært interessant å se ytelsen med 300/2,8 også. F. eks for å se om den er god nok til å kunne erstatte TC17 II.

Roy Mangersnes said...

Monica: Telekonvertere øker brennvidden på dine teleobjektiv. TC14 med 1,4x forstørrelse, TC17 med 1,7x og TC20 med hele 2x forstørrelse. Det betyr at en 200mm blir en 400mm. Dette fører til tap av noe lysstyrke og detaljering i bildet. 2x konvertere har tidligere vært svært dårlige i bruk, men den nye TC20 fra Nikon kan veldig gjerne brukes.

Skal se hva jeg kan få til på 300/2,8 Øyvind.

Mvh, Roy

ROECOM said...

Hva med en sammenligning av TC-17EII og den nye 20EIII på en 70-200 VRII?

Ville vært morsomt å se om de er noe kvalitetsforskjell.

Alfred Haram said...

Likte veldig godt det første ternebildet. Skapte en fin diagonal i bildet. Er selv en Nikon-mann og har hele tiden fortalt å ikke bruke 2x converter så kvaliteten blir nok bedre...